The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear the Trump administration's appeal in a fight over canceled University of California research grants, leaving in place a lower-court ruling that the cuts likely violated the First Amendment. The decision means the grants — canceled because the research was seen as promoting diversity, equity and inclusion — must continue to be restored while the case proceeds.
![]() |
| The United States Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. On Monday, the court declined to hear the Trump administration's appeal in a case over canceled University of California research grants. |
The Case at the Center
The case, known as Trump v. Thakur, reached the Supreme Court on the justices' November 16 order list, where it appeared among a long list of denied petitions. As is usually the case with such denials, the court gave no explanation for its decision, and no justice publicly noted a dissent. A denial of review is not a ruling on the merits of a case; it simply means the court chose not to take it up.
But the practical effect is significant. By refusing the appeal, the justices left standing a May 26 ruling by the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which upheld a preliminary injunction requiring federal agencies to reinstate grants that had been terminated because of executive orders targeting diversity, equity and inclusion programs.
The dispute began shortly after President Donald Trump took office, when he signed executive orders in January 2025 targeting DEI and what the administration called "gender ideology." Federal agencies, including the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities, then cut off grants to researchers across the University of California system, one of the world's leading public research institutions.
The researchers fought back in court. A class action filed in 2025, led by University of California researcher Neeta Thakur, accused the administration of violating the researchers' First Amendment rights through funding cuts based on the content and viewpoint of their research. The terminated grants funded projects that included efforts to foster discussion about racial equity in science education and to expand science education opportunities for Indigenous youth, according to court papers cited by Reuters. Other affected projects covered U.S. history, disease research and biology.
The amounts at issue depend on how they are counted. Reuters reported that the appeal concerned cuts to about $59 million in federal grants to University of California researchers, while CNN reported that about $150 million in National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities grants was at stake. The broader picture is larger still: between January and July of last year, the White House terminated more than $900 million in grants to UC researchers, including nearly $600 million at UCLA alone, according to CalMatters.
A Long Fight Through the Lower Courts
The researchers won the early rounds. U.S. District Judge Rita Lin in San Francisco halted the administration's termination of the DEI-related grants, finding that the researchers were likely to win their claim that the cuts amounted to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination — in other words, that the government had punished researchers for the perceived viewpoint of their work.
The administration appealed, and on May 26, a three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit upheld Judge Lin's order for the group of researchers whose grants were cut over DEI, known in the case as the DEI Termination Class. The panel — Judges Richard Paez, Morgan Christen and Roopali Desai — sided with the researchers, holding that they were likely to succeed on their First Amendment claim.
The Trump administration then asked the Supreme Court to intervene, appealing to the high court in August. On Monday, the justices said no.
Erwin Chemerinsky, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, told Reuters that the court's action means the lower court's ruling against the administration stands and that "all of the grants that were cut off based on the perceived viewpoint of the research must continue to be restored."
What the Administration Argued
Solicitor General D. John Sauer, the administration's top appellate attorney, framed the dispute as a shift in funding priorities rather than a free-speech violation. The First Amendment, the Justice Department argued in its appeal, "does not prohibit the government from declining to award competitive grants that fund research projects that promote DEI."
The argument reflects a broader position the administration has taken across its second-term agenda: that the federal government, as a funder, may choose which research to support and may steer money away from programs it opposes. The Justice Department argued that the lower courts had wrongly treated a funding decision as censorship.
The researchers and their lawyers argued the opposite — that the terminations were not a neutral reallocation of funds but a targeted punishment of disfavored viewpoints. Judge Lin and the 9th Circuit panel agreed that the researchers were likely to prove that point, and the Supreme Court's refusal to disturb those rulings leaves that finding in place for now.
The case also touched on a procedural question about where such challenges should be heard. By declining the appeal, the court allowed the cases to proceed in federal district courts rather than the specialized federal claims court, according to CNN.
A Court That Has Usually Sided With Trump
The outcome is striking in part because of the court that delivered it. The Supreme Court has a 6-3 conservative majority and, as Reuters noted, has been highly deferential toward Trump's aggressive use of executive authority, vastly expanding the power of the presidency in a series of recent decisions.
Against that backdrop, the refusal to take up the UC grants case stands out. It does not reverse the court's broader direction, and because a denial of certiorari carries no reasoning, it offers no guidance about how the justices view the underlying First Amendment question. But it is a concrete loss for the administration in a fight it chose to escalate to the nation's highest court — and a win for university researchers who have spent nearly two years litigating to keep their funding.
![]() |
| A view of the University of California, Berkeley campus. The University of California system is one of the world's leading public research institutions. |
What This Means
For the University of California researchers at the heart of the case, Monday's decision means their grants stay restored while the litigation continues. The preliminary injunction that Judge Lin issued remains in effect, and the federal agencies involved must keep funding the DEI-related grants that were cut.
For the administration, the decision narrows — at least for now — one tool it has used to reshape federal research funding. If the government cannot cancel existing grants because of the perceived viewpoint of the research, its ability to use funding terminations to enforce its policy preferences is more limited than it argued in court. The ruling does not prevent the administration from setting future funding priorities, but it does suggest that retroactively cutting grants already awarded carries legal risk.
For universities and researchers beyond California, the case is a signal. The Supreme Court's refusal to intervene leaves the 9th Circuit's reasoning intact within its jurisdiction, which covers the western United States, and it gives other researchers challenging similar terminations a favorable precedent to cite. Whether courts in other circuits reach the same conclusion remains to be seen, but the UC researchers' win is now the most prominent data point in that debate.
The decision also matters for the politics of the moment. The administration has made its campaign against DEI programs a central theme of its second term, and a Supreme Court that has often backed the president declined to help it here. That does not mean the campaign is over — far from it — but it does mean the administration's legal path to canceling research grants over viewpoint is, for the moment, blocked.
![]() |
| A researcher at work in a university science laboratory. The canceled grants funded projects including science education and disease research. |
What Happens Next
The case now returns to Judge Lin's court in San Francisco, where the class action will continue toward a final resolution. The preliminary injunction protects the grants in the meantime, but the underlying question — whether the terminations violated the First Amendment — has not yet received a final ruling.
The fight is also widening. Lawyers for the UC researchers were due back in a lower court on Tuesday to argue that the Trump administration's termination of Department of Energy grants was also illegal, according to CalMatters. That hearing could extend the same legal reasoning to another large pool of research funding.
Meanwhile, the administration must decide whether to adjust its approach to research funding or to test the issue again in a different case, in a different circuit, where it might find a more sympathetic court. For now, though, the grants at the center of Trump v. Thakur are safe — and the researchers who sued to save them have won the most important round of their case without the Supreme Court ever hearing an argument.



Post a Comment