A federal judge in San Francisco on Friday evening barred the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security from threatening election workers with criminal prosecution over how they handle ballots, just four days before the November 3 midterm elections. In a temporary restraining order, U.S. District Judge Trina L. Thompson ruled that the administration's pressure campaign likely violated the Voting Rights Act's ban on voter intimidation and risked interfering with election administration and disenfranchising lawful voters.
The order, in Service Employees International Union v. U.S. Department of Justice, applies nationwide and runs until 5 p.m. on November 16, according to reports on it. It was granted without waiting for the government to respond. "Ballots have already been issued. Americans have already begun voting. Workers have already begun processing ballots," Thompson wrote, according to reporting on the eight-page order.
The ruling landed the same day a federal appeals court separately rejected the administration's emergency bid to force California to set aside the mail ballots of about 20,000 voters it claims may not be citizens. Together, the two October 30 decisions marked a sharp judicial check on the administration's election enforcement push.
The Order, in Plain Terms
Thompson's order blocks a specific set of federal actions while it remains in effect. The Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security may not threaten, intimidate or coerce state and local election officials into changing how they process ballots based solely on the administration's claim that particular voters are ineligible, according to CNN, Reuters and Fox News.
The agencies also may not demand that officials remove specific registered voters from the rolls, refuse them ballots, or segregate and withhold their ballots on that basis alone, nor threaten workers with prosecution for refusing such demands or for counting ballots as the law requires.
The judge wrote that when state and local employees administer the 2026 midterm election in accordance with the law, "they do not violate federal criminal law even if a particular ballot belongs to a registered voter alleged by Defendants to be ineligible to vote," according to multiple reports quoting the order.
The order also requires the administration to tell every state and local government that received its ballot letters that the threats in those letters have been blocked, and to disclose to the court any pending search warrant applications, grand jury subpoenas or other demands for election materials tied to its lists.
Thompson, appointed by former President Joe Biden, found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their Voting Rights Act claim and did not rule for now on their other claims. The case was brought by the Service Employees International Union, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, the League of United Latin American Citizens and the NAACP, which accused Attorney General Todd Blanche and other top Justice Department officials of a coordinated campaign to intimidate state and local officials. The Justice Department had no immediate comment, Reuters reported.
A Second Court Blow the Same Day
Hours earlier on Friday, a three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals denied the Justice Department's emergency request in United States v. California, seeking to force California to set aside ballots from about 20,000 registered voters it claims may not be citizens.
The 2-1 order upheld a ruling by U.S. District Judge David O. Carter, who had refused the same request on October 28. Carter had warned that granting it would, in his words, wreak havoc on the election and potentially disenfranchise thousands of lawfully registered voters.
The appeals panel agreed that separation was not workable at this stage. "As the district court found, and we discern no clear error, there is no feasible way to identify and segregate the ballots of specific individuals without potentially catastrophic effects on the entire system," the panel wrote, according to reports quoting the order.
The majority consisted of Judge Mark J. Bennett, appointed by President Donald Trump in his first term, and Judge Gabriel P. Sanchez, appointed by Biden. Judge Patrick J. Bumatay, also a Trump appointee, dissented, arguing that setting the ballots aside would not cancel any votes but would allow time for citizenship to be verified. California has said the administration's list is highly unreliable and likely includes many citizens, with the state telling the court that about one in four voters on the list were born in the United States. The 20,000 figure is the department's claim, not a court finding.
The ruling keeps those ballots in the count for now and could set up a further appeal, with Reuters noting it could lead to a showdown at the Supreme Court days before the midterms. The administration had sued California on October 15, after mail ballots had already been sent to all registered voters in the state.
How the Pressure Campaign Built Up
The court orders cap a fast-moving sequence of federal steps in October. The Justice Department sent letters to election officials in all 50 states this week threatening potential prosecution if they failed to preserve election records, and a week earlier sent similar letters to every California county demanding cooperation in identifying potential noncitizens on their voter rolls. The plaintiffs' case, filed on Friday, moved unusually fast, with Thompson granting the order the same evening on the grounds that the public interest weighed in the plaintiffs' favor so close to Election Day. Temporary restraining orders are short-term emergency measures, not final judgments, and this order does not decide every claim the plaintiffs raised.
What the Administration Argues
The administration has said its efforts are aimed at preventing noncitizen voting and protecting election integrity. Noncitizen voting in federal elections is illegal, and the administration has argued that states should cooperate in identifying voters who may be ineligible.
Its California lawsuit rested on that argument: that ballots from voters on its list should be separated and verified before being counted, so that unlawful votes would not be mixed in with lawful ones.
Critics, including the plaintiffs and California officials, dispute both the method and the data. They argue that the lists are unreliable, that singling out voters by that method risks sweeping up citizens, and that threats of prosecution can chill lawful election administration. Thompson's order sided with the view that the administration's actions were likely to interfere with election administration and disenfranchise lawful voters, even though the administration says its goal is to stop unlawful voting.
What This Means
The immediate practical effect is a pause on the federal pressure tactics the judges addressed. Election workers in every state can, under the Thompson order, keep processing ballots as the law requires. In California, counties keep counting the disputed mail ballots rather than pulling them out of the stream.
The political context makes the timing significant. All 435 House seats and 35 Senate seats are on the ballot on November 3. Democrats need a net gain of three seats to take the House majority from Republicans, who currently hold 219 seats to 214 for Democrats, and a net gain of four to reach 51 seats in the Senate. With nearly 48 million ballots already cast early, according to election trackers, the orders arrive while millions of votes are already in the system and being processed.
For voters, the orders do not change who is eligible to vote or how ballots are cast; they concern what
officials may be told to do with ballots after they are cast, and what may be threatened if officials decline.
What Happens Next
The calendar is tight. Under the Thompson order, the Justice Department must respond by noon on Monday, November 2, and a hearing on a longer preliminary injunction is set for November 13. The restraining order itself runs until November 16, which means it will still be in place on Election Day and through the initial counting period.
The administration could seek to narrow, modify or appeal the order, and it could take the California dispute further, including to the Supreme Court. Any such move would face the same timing problem the judges identified: ballots are already issued and voting is under way.
For now, the message from both courts is consistent: election officials should follow the law as written, not federal threats tied to disputed lists, and ballots should not be pulled from the count on the basis of those lists alone.



Post a Comment